Ask any nonprofit leader what culprit keeps them up at night, and there is a high probability they will say money. And by money, I mean not enough of it.
A growing mission is exciting. More people served, more impact in our communities. But growth necessitates more resources. More people. Larger facilities and more sophisticated infrastructure.
Growth inevitably means a larger team, and employing people costs money.
Over the last few posts, I have been examining the storms leaders face. In my book Unlikely Good, I describe this as one of the financial storms leaders must prepare to weather:
The Payroll Pressure Front
Hiring the right people is crucial for scaling the good work you want to accomplish. At some point, you will need to add people to the payroll.
There is no getting around the fact that increasing your team’s headcount will create a pressure front that you will feel for some time. Every human you add increases the payroll demands.
People deserve to be paid fairly at market levels that allow them to take care of their own needs and those of their families. I have always felt a strong sense of responsibility to offer the best compensation the organization can feasibly provide.
While employees should be mission-committed, I am not a fan of accomplishing the mission on the backs of employees; that is, underpaying people because they love the cause. Of course, you will struggle in the nonprofit sector to pay people what they can make in the for-profit sector.
Operating nonprofits is vastly more challenging than operating for-profit organizations, in my opinion. In a for-profit organization, you sell goods or services that create revenue. As you sell more goods and services, you generate more income to grow your operation.
In the nonprofit world, you are expected to provide high-quality goods and services for charitable purposes, giving away those goods or services at little or no cost. You must go out and find your revenue, primarily through fundraising. As more people desire your goods and services, you will need to raise more money to pay for them.
The nonprofit organization must provide excellent service and raise revenue to support it, a sizable challenge.
To grow Logos Academy typically means adding sections of grade levels, such as another kindergarten class. This equates to an additional teacher, a new aide, and so on. Additionally, over time, this will result in the addition of extra class sections in future grade levels and increased support services for those students.
The best way to handle the “payroll pressure front” is to plan for it. Develop a comprehensive long-range staffing plan and adhere to it as closely as possible. Calculate the cost of each addition to headcount and plan how you will fund the position.
Do your best to avoid hiring erratically, or you will increase payroll pressure at your peril.
Anticipate that you will be faced with tough decisions as employees ask for salary increases. Finding and keeping good employees is usually easier and less risky than going to the job market to replace those people.
Expect that the cost of employees will continue to rise as inflation pushes higher. I have yet to see a year where the cost of healthcare benefits has not increased significantly.
Payroll pressure is a real concern, but it can be effectively managed through planning.
Plan for the Pressure
Growth is a wonderful thing, but growth without a plan can quickly become a financial storm.
As leaders, we have a responsibility not only to advance the mission but also to care for the people who make that mission possible. That means thinking carefully about when to hire, how to compensate employees fairly, and how to sustain those commitments over time.
Take the time to anticipate where your organization’s headcount will need to increase. Don’t overdo it and add too much to the budget in one fiscal year. Instead of hiring the two positions you need to add, can you be creative and hire one and leverage a committed volunteer as a temporary measure?
Some of my greatest mistakes have been adding too many people too quickly. The cultural pain of trimming the payroll is tough to weather.
You need to ensure that your revenues can keep pace with your budget’s expense line. I’ll admit that it’s one of the more challenging realities nonprofit leaders face.
The payroll pressure front may be inevitable, but with thoughtful planning, it doesn't have to overwhelm your organization.